Consider how unusual it is for the exact breaking point of a big-time rock band to be seen on film.
For the Eagles, the end came abruptly at a political fundraiser in 1980. Don Felder didn't want to be there. Glenn Frey didn't like his attitude. Add years of resentment and as they performed, threats exchanged under the music. Fists didn't fly, but each stalked into separate limousines, and the Eagles were toast for 14 years.
It's one of the fascinating moments in "History of the Eagles," a documentary that airs on Showtime Friday and Saturday. The film has two parts just like the band, which has been together again since 1994.
Frey, 64, said it was time to get the story on film while the health and memories of everyone involved were intact. The Eagles courted filmmaker Alex Gibney, who won an Academy Award for his 2007 documentary on torture, "Taxi to the Dark Side." Gibney expressed interest if he was free to tell a real story, not just an authorized one, and the Eagles agreed. He talked to each former member and to associates like David Geffen, whose business relationship with the band ended badly.
Another key was having enough footage to make the story come alive. Here he got lucky; although Frey and co-leader Don Henley were suspicious of outsiders during the height of the Eagles' fame, they had the foresight to allow some filming, including interview and concert footage from 1977 and that ill-fated 1980 benefit. Film was
"Theirs is the classic rock 'n' roll story -- scruffy kids hook up in L.A., form a band and have enormous success and at the height of their success, they break up," Gibney said. "It's a rock 'n' roll fable."
It also details a fertile time and place for music. Frey describes learning how to write songs through the floorboards of his apartment: Jackson Browne lived downstairs, and Frey would hear him work on songs until the lyrics and melody were just right.
Frey and Henley prove gifted storytellers for "History of the Eagles." It was different back in the 1970s, when they kept such talk to a minimum.
"We sort of felt that it was time to open the door a little wider," Frey said. "With the Eagles, we had opened the door a crack and let people look in. Let's just call it effective mystique management. When you're an artist, one of the greatest allies you can have is the imagination of your audience. It's better to paint a picture than explain things."
He hopes the film clears up misconceptions, primarily that the band's time was dominated by squabbling. They worked hard and had a lot of fun, Frey said.
Oh, but they could fight with the best of them. Those stories enliven the film: Bernie Leadon exiting after pouring a can of beer over Frey's head; Randy Meisner leaving when he became reluctant to sing "Take It to the Limit," his signature song; Felder ending his association with the reunion after getting a brutal business ultimatum from Frey.
Frey's reasons for dissatisfaction with Felder are clear, and though Felder is interviewed, his side of the story is murkier. The film's most poignant moment comes when Felder breaks down and walks away from the camera when talking about it. "It just broke my heart," he said.
Frey said there were never any serious problems between him and Henley.
"We just grew tired together," he said. "That's the way it played out. The Eagles became such a burden. I think Don and I just sort of succumbed to the weight that we felt after 'Hotel California' went through the roof. You know, it could have ended there. Instead for us, we were able to, as Don said, have a second act."
Since the Eagles famously said they wouldn't reform "until hell freezes over," their reunion was cheekily called the "Hell Freezes Over Tour." "The time off did everyone good," Frey said. "I know when I came back to play in the band in 1994, I was a much better musician ... I was more grounded as a person. When we all came back together, we had all sort of grown up, dragged kicking and screaming into adulthood."
'history of the eagles'
Airing: 8 p.m. Friday and Saturday, Showtime