Clinton took questions for about an hour during a mortgage-crisis roundtable at Everett & Jones barbecue restaurant on Broadway and Second Street, trying to allay people's fears while stumping for his wife's presidential campaign.
His presence here in California, while U.S. Sen. Hillary Clinton still has the Nevada caucus and South Carolina primary ahead of her, may indicate just how important California's Feb. 5 primary will be in deciding who gets the Democratic nomination.
The choice of topic was significant as well, indicating the Clinton campaign's desire to focus on a slumping U.S. economy after seven years under the Bush administration's stewardship.
These years have seen "a deliberate attempt to give people more mortgages on more attractive terms because we weren't achieving economic growth any other way," the two-term former president told a hand-picked group of community leaders, homeowners and campaign supporters Wednesday.
The Bush administration has had "no strategy in this decade to create more jobs ... and create more income for ordinary people," he added.
As a crowd gathered outside, Clinton said there are "very few villains" to blame in this crisis, as the road to this particular hell was paved mostly with the good intentions of buyers who wanted to own homes and mortgage lenders who thought property values would continue to rise while interest rates stayed low.
"This happened because everyone assumed the only stable part of our economy was home ownership," he said.
But even veteran economists didn't seem to see interest rates would rise "if we kept borrowing money like a drunken sailor as a country," Clinton said. What has happened is "a systematic failing of the American economy and the way the mortgage market works," with homeowners many of whom never missed a monthly payment until those payments suddenly ballooned out of control taking the hit.
With the net cost to society for every foreclosure hovering somewhere around $250,000 what with homeowners' losses, neighbors' lowered property values and other costs "the dumbest thing we can do here is nothing... The most expensive way to handle this problem is to let the foreclosures occur," Clinton said.
His wife's plan, which includes freezing all subprime foreclosures for 90 days and creating a $30 billion Emergency Housing Crisis Fund to support states and cities in helping embattled residents refinance their homes with affordable monthly payments would help people keep their homes for the next few years until Washington can come up with a longer-term solution, he said.
Republican National Committee spokesman Paul Lindsay issued a statement Wednesday saying Hillary Clinton's plan "would result in massive tax hikes ... As long as she and her surrogates attempt to mislead voters on these critical issues, Clinton will continue to lack the trust that Americans expect."
Paul Williams of Hayward said he fears the Clintons' prescription for the mortgage crisis will fare no better than their 1993 health care reform plan, sunk by conservatives and the insurance industry.
But Bill Clinton replied, "There's really nobody on the other side," in this situation, other than a small number of conservatives philosophically opposed to any government intervention. Nobody stands to gain if this crisis continues, he said, adding that "the real debate here is how much can we do without misleading people" who never should've qualified for a mortgage in the first place.
Pamela Dela Cruz, a broker with RE/MAX Accord in Lafayette, said the government at least should make it quicker and easier for families finding themselves in dire straits to sell their homes before foreclosure. Clinton replied he agrees, and said his wife proposed such a bill but it couldn't be enacted in time to help those already under the gun.
"You've given me some good ideas, I'll take them back and talk with Hillary about them tonight," Clinton promised.
Oakland Mayor Ron Dellums, whom Hillary Clinton named her campaign's urban-policy chairman in October, moderated Wednesday's forum and at the end praised Bill Clinton as "perhaps the best political listener I've ever encountered."
While the mortgage crisis may have its roots in global and national economics, he said, Oakland remains the nation's 10th-hardest-hit city in foreclosures. It's in cities such as this that peoples' homes and livelihoods are on the line, "and that's where the issues ultimately have to be wrestled to the ground," Dellums said.
Bill Clinton took a few questions from reporters after the roundtable. He seemed to take umbrage when asked about a federal lawsuit filed Friday to halt the Nevada Democratic Party's plan to hold caucus meetings at nine Las Vegas Strip hotels. The plaintiffs Hillary Clinton supporters including the state teachers union and some party activists claim this would give the Culinary Workers Union, which has endorsed Barack Obama for the president and represents the hotel workers, undue influence on the vote.
"Their votes will be counted five times more powerfully," Bill Clinton said Wednesday, which in a "one-man, one-vote country" should be an offense to all. He noted it was a group of supporters, not the campaign itself, which sued. "I read about it in the newspaper."